Snippets

Alaskan Folly.

Four people are on the Alaskan ballot for Senator. Two are named Dan Sullivan. One is the Republican incumbent, and the other is virtually unknown. According to a New York Times article, the “other” Dan Sullivan was recruited by supporters of Democratic nominee Mary Peltola (but not by Peltola herself) to confuse voters. Republicans are voicing outrage. I am surprised by the outcry. Did anyone think that the “other” Dan Sullivan was on the ballot for any reason other than to be some sort of spoiler?

The Alaskan tactic is just another version of what both parties have done many times. One party, for example, has sometimes given aid and support to an extreme candidate in the other party’s primary, thinking that the extreme candidate will be easier to beat in the general election. Sometimes a party has aided a third party thinking that the third-party candidate will siphon votes from the major-party opponent. Reports, for example, said that Republicans helped the Green Party’s Jill Stein to get on the ballot in some states.

However, the story of two Dan Sullivans reminds me of a similar shenanigan in a different context. A Broadway play produced by David Merrick, Subways Are for Sleeping, got uniformly poor reviews from the New York critics. Merrick sought out people with the same names as the critics, such as Howard Taubman and Walter Kerr. He invited them to a performance and elicited blurbs from them such as “One of the few great musical comedies of the last twenty years,” and “A fabulous musical. I loved it.” Merrick placed the quotes along with pictures of the namesakes (Who knew what the actual critics looked like?) in a newspaper ad saying seven out of seven loved Subways. The flop play ran for almost another six months.

Yodeling

I watched a few minutes of a TV travel show about the Alps. It showed street performers in a touristy town. There was yodeling. That evening while getting ready for bed, an NPR segment featured yodeling. I had now heard yodeling twice in a day! I used to hear it more because a lot of country singers once yodeled. I thought I remembered that even my favorite of the singing cowboys, Roy Rogers, occasionally yodeled. The next day I went to YouTube and was pleased to find that some of my memories were still correct and that Roy Rogers did indeed yodel. (It does not seem right just to call him Rogers, but it would be ok to just say “Roy.”) As often happens with YouTube, that led me to other clips, and I heard more yodelers. I realized that during each of these yodeling encounters, I smiled while listening to the minute or two of the distinctive vocalizations. A whole hour of yodeling might be bad for one’s mental health, but a few minutes can make you feel lighthearted. Perhaps in these troubled times we all ought to take a break each day to listen to some yodeling. I, therefore, considered it good news when I was told that a new Broadway show about the life of Dolly Parton will have yodeling.

A Tribute?

Sir Patrick Stewart, the marvelous actor, just died. I will always remember him as Macbeth in a production of the Shakespeare play that took my breath away. I guess that many more will know him as Captain Jean-Luc Picard in Star Trek: The Next Generation. Whenever I watched that show, I marveled that even far into the future, humans had not learned how to grow hair. Perhaps as a tribute to Stewart, I should finally shave my head.

In Spite of the People

It’s election season, but now it always feels that way since we seem to have a perpetual election season. This campaign stretch may feel different from past ones, however, because of the president who seems to have transformed the political landscape. On the other hand, although he has held the executive office for closing in on four years, perceptions of him have changed remarkably little during that time. He seems neither to have attracted many new supporters nor has he driven many away. He has inhabited the same landscape since his election.

If this election season is different from the last one, it is not due to Trump who remains the same but because Hillary Clinton is not the Democratic candidate. For whatever the reason, many voters who did not vote for Trump could not vote for Clinton. They voted for third party candidates instead, and in key states these votes for Libertarians and Greens gave Trump pluralities and the decisive electoral votes. Trump, although he is not about to admit it and perhaps in a delusion does not believe it, did not get the most votes in the country, but he also did not get majorities in key states that he won.

Trump certainly has passionate followers. This gives the impression that he unleashed a new conservative juggernaut and that the last election was a revolution, a Trump Revolution. That has been overstated. If there was an electoral transformation, it was not by a majority of the electorate. Even if it is true that he attracted many voters that had not before voted Republican, we should also realize that he drove away at least as many voters who could have been expected to vote Republican.

          Compare 2012 and 2016 election results. (Different sources do not always give the same nationwide vote totals, but, for consistency, I am using figures from the Federal Election Commission website.) In 2012, Mitt Romney got 60,932,152 votes. Four years later, Trump received 62,984,825. Trump got two million more votes than Romney but that does not mean that he made great inroads into previously Democratic voters.          Instead, about 7.5 million more people voted in 2016 than 2012. With more voters as the country’s population increased, it is not surprising that Trump got more votes than Romney, but he did not get even close to a majority of that increased vote. Perhaps more revealing than the vote totals for Romney and Trump is the percentage of the vote for each. Romney received 47.21 percent of the nationwide ballots, while Trump got 46.09 percent. In other words, there was no dramatic swing to him compared to the previous election. Analyses I have seen expend a good deal of effort dissecting the voters Trump attracted; they also ought to equally examine the voters Trump drove away. For example, The Great Revolt: Inside the Populist Coalition Reshaping American Politics by Salena Zito and Brad Todd mentions that “Trump’s margin was weaker than Romney’s in 86 of the 100 most educated counties—a fact that held true regardless of the jurisdiction’s normal partisan leanings.” But the authors set out only to interview voters in some swing states who shifted from Obama to Trump when there were at least as many voters who swung away from Trump. If that first group of Obama/Trump voters constitutes some new populist coalition, how should we label the at-least-as-significant second group of Romney/not-Trump voters?

          The real takeaway from the 2016 election is not that Trump did so well, but that Clinton did so poorly. Even with more voters in 2016 than 2012, Clinton got slightly fewer votes than Obama—65,853,516 to 65,899,660—with a big drop in the percentage of the ballots. Obama got a majority of the vote, 51.6 percent, while Clinton got 48.18 percent. Trump did not get a higher percentage than Romney four years earlier, but Clinton got significantly less than Obama. Wasn’t the revolution not so much for Trump as against Clinton?

          Perhaps the real revolution in 2016 was not for Trump but in favor of third parties. Obama and Romney together accounted for 98.8 percent of the vote. Clinton and Trump together only received 94.3 percent. The combined Libertarian and Green vote increased by over 300 percent. That third-party total went from 1.7 million in 2012 to 5.9 million in 2016.

          Much has been made of states that Obama won, but whose electoral votes went to Trump and swung the election to him. Let’s look more closely at three of them: Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin.

(Continued August 17)